Is a voice vote on a Resolution whose amended form was read out without objection a valid vote in that form?
Coram: Justice G.Arul Murugan · Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari
A voice vote on a Resolution whose amended form was read out without objection is a valid vote in that form.
Yes. A voice vote on a Resolution whose amended form was read out without objection is a valid vote in that form. There is no requirement, statutory or otherwise, that every sentence of a composite resolution be separately voted upon once the House has been told, and has accepted without demur, that the Resolution before it stands amended. (¶23)
Constitution of India — Art.212 — Art.194 — Art.226 — Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly Rules — r.104 — r.286 — Proceedings in the Legislature — Irregularity of procedure — Constitution of India — Art.212 — Internal procedure of the House — Beyond the reach of a writ court — Held: A complaint that a clause was incorporated into a Resolution without a separate motion, seconding, debate and division is a complaint about internal procedure, which Article 212 places beyond the reach of a writ court. (¶13, 14) Constitution of India — Art.212 — Want of jurisdiction — Illegality alone remains examinable — Held further: The immunity protects the House's proceedings from being reopened merely because a rule of procedure was departed from; only a proceeding suffering from illegality, and not mere irregularity, remains open to scrutiny. (¶12) Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly Rules — r.104 — Voice vote — No separate vote on each sentence — Held further: A voice vote taken on a Resolution after its amended form has been read out to the House without objection is a valid vote on the Resolution in that form. (¶23) Constitution of India — Art.226 — Silence at the vote — Challenge not entertained — Held further: A Member who was present when an amendment was proposed, read out and voted upon, and who did not then object, cannot later ask a court to treat his own silence as a nullity. Writ petition dismissed. (¶25, 28)
Headnote
You've used your free headnotes this month
The answer above and the Court's own paragraphs stay free. LexStreak's full headnote on this judgment needs an account — a free one opens it again.
Create my free accountOne judgment a day. That's the whole habit.
Read the full text of Agri S.S.Krishnamurthy v. The Secretary — and get the Madras High Court's output as a five-minute daily read, with plain-language headnotes and the questions each judgment settles.
Create my free accountFree forever plan · 30 seconds · data stays in India