What probative value do pre-constitutional family records carry in verifying a Scheduled Tribe claim?

High probative value. The pre-constitutional records of the grandfather and father recorded their caste as ‘Koli’, and relying on those records the claim of belonging to the ‘Tokre Koli’ Scheduled Tribe was rejected. This Court found no error in the conclusion reached by the Scrutiny Committee and affirmed by the High Court, which also accepted the finding that a Caste Validity Certificate granted to a cousin had been obtained by misrepresentation.

Constitution of India — Art.142 — Scheduled Tribe certificate — Caste Scrutiny Committee — Invalidation of tribe claim — Protection of retiral and pensionary benefits — Constitution of India — Art.142 — Invalidated tribe claim — Complete justice in exceptional circumstances — Held: Invalidation of a caste or tribe claim upon verification ordinarily has consequences in law, but in exceptional circumstances where the equities of the case so warrant the power under Article 142 may be exercised to do complete justice. (¶13) Constitution of India — Art.142 — Long service ending in superannuation — Retiral benefits protected — Held further: Where the individual concerned served for more than three decades and retired on superannuation during the pendency of the appeal, the service rendered is protected for the limited purpose of computation and release of retiral and pensionary benefits. (¶14) Constitution of India — Art.142 — Scope of the protection — No validation of the tribe claim — Held further: Such protection does not amount to validation or recognition of the tribe claim, and neither the individual nor any member of the family may claim any future benefit on the basis of the invalidated caste certificate. (¶15) Scheduled Tribe certificate — Pre-constitutional family records — High probative value — Disposal — On facts, held: Pre-constitutional records of the grandfather and father recording the caste as ‘Koli’ possess high probative value, and the claim to the ‘Tokre Koli’ Scheduled Tribe stands rejected. Appeal allowed only as to retiral benefits; the invalidation is not interfered with. (¶7, 16)

One judgment a day. That's the whole habit.

Read the full text of SHIRISH PANDHARINATH PATIL v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS — and get the Supreme Court's output as a five-minute daily read, with plain-language headnotes and the questions each judgment settles.

Free forever plan · 30 seconds · data stays in India